The Imaginary ‘Thinker’: How Thought Creates Time, Space, and Duality

Introduction

In our everyday experience, we perceive the world as a collection of separate objects and events scattered across time and space. We often feel like an independent ‘I’ existing apart from the world around us. But what if these beliefs are merely constructs of thought? Let us explore together how the mind weaves the illusion of time, space, and duality, and how self-inquiry can reveal the reality that lies beyond these constructs.

1. Thought and the Illusion of Time and Space

Our minds have a tendency to organize reality in terms of time and space. We believe that the past lies behind us, the future ahead, and that we occupy a specific location in space. But is this truly how things are?

The Illusion of Time

When we contemplate the past or the future, we find that they exist only as thoughts in the present moment. The past appears as memories, and the future as anticipations or plans. In reality, we never directly experience anything outside the now. Time, as we commonly understand it, is a mental construct born from thought.

Consider this: when you recall an event from yesterday, that memory arises in your consciousness now. It is a thought occurring in the present, not a direct experience of the past. The past and future are abstractions; they have no existence outside of the thoughts that represent them in the present moment.

Deepening the Understanding

Let’s delve a bit deeper. Imagine watching a movie. The story unfolds with a sense of time—there’s a past, present, and future within the narrative. But all of it is happening on the screen now. Similarly, our sense of personal time is like a story projected onto the screen of consciousness, always and only in the present moment.

The Illusion of Space

Similarly, we perceive space as the distance between objects and between ourselves and others. This experience of separation is created by labeling and conceptualizing our perceptions. When we focus on our direct experience, without the intermediary of thought, we discover that all phenomena arise within the same field of awareness, without actual separation.

For example, when you hear a bird singing, there is no distance between you and the sound. The song arises immediately in your consciousness. The apparent space between you and the bird is conceptual—created by thought. In your direct experience, there is only the seamless experience of hearing.

Going Deeper

Think of the ocean and its waves. Waves appear separate, with distinct shapes and sizes, but they are never anything other than the ocean expressing itself. Similarly, all experiences arise within and as consciousness itself. The perception of separation in space is an overlay of thought upon the unity of experience.

2. The Imaginary ‘Thinker’

We often regard ourselves as the ‘I’ who thinks, feels, and acts. But who or what is this thinker, really?

The ‘Thinker’ as Thought

The sense of a separate self that produces thoughts is itself a thought. There is no independent ‘I’ standing apart from the thoughts that arise. Thoughts emerge spontaneously in consciousness without a personal author orchestrating them.

Try this exercise: Ask yourself, “Can I find the source of my thoughts? Where do they come from?” You may notice that thoughts simply appear, unbidden, without an individual thinker creating them. The notion of a thinker is itself another thought that arises within awareness.

Exploring More Deeply

Consider the moments just before a thought arises. Is there a thinker preparing to think? Or does the thought simply emerge? Even the thought “I am thinking” is just another thought appearing in awareness. There is only thinking happening; the ‘I’ who claims ownership is a mental construct.

Letting Go of the Ego

The ego—the sense of a separate self—is maintained by identification with thoughts and beliefs. When we see that the ‘I’ is merely a thought, this illusion begins to dissolve. We realize that our true being is the awareness in which all experiences, including thoughts of ‘I,’ appear.

Another exercise: Observe your thoughts without identifying with them. See them as passing clouds in the sky of your consciousness. Notice how they come and go, while the aware presence that you are remains constant.

Deeper Insight

By recognizing that the thinker is imaginary, we free ourselves from the confines of the ego. This realization doesn’t negate our ability to function; rather, it liberates us from the unnecessary burdens of self-centered thinking, allowing actions to arise naturally from the intelligence of consciousness itself.

3. Thought and the Emergence of Duality

Duality is the perception of separation between ‘I’ and ‘other,’ between subject and object. Thought plays a crucial role in creating this apparent split.

Thought Creates Boundaries

By labeling and categorizing our experiences, thought divides reality into separate parts. This process creates artificial boundaries that do not exist in our direct experience.

For instance, we see a tree as distinct from the sky around it. But in our immediate perception, colors and shapes form a unified visual field within our awareness. The separation arises only when we conceptualize and label what we perceive.

A Deeper Exploration

Let’s examine this further. When you taste a fruit, before thought intervenes to label and categorize, there is just the pure experience of flavor. There is no separate taster and tasted—only tasting. Thought splits this seamless experience into subject and object, creating the illusion of duality.

The Unity of Direct Experience

When we direct our attention to immediate experience without mental labels, we discover that there is no actual separation. Subject and object merge into a single, seamless flow of consciousness.

Try this exercise: Close your eyes and listen to the sounds around you. Avoid naming or interpreting them. Notice how the sounds arise effortlessly in your awareness, without distance or division. There is just hearing—no separate hearer and heard.

Going Deeper Still

In moments of profound beauty or deep meditation, we often experience this non-dual awareness naturally. The boundaries soften, and there is a sense of oneness with all that is. This reveals the ever-present reality beneath the overlay of thought.

Conclusion

By recognizing that time, space, and the sense of a separate ‘I’ are constructs of thought, we open the door to a deeper realization of our true nature. We discover that we are not the limited individual we imagined ourselves to be but the limitless awareness in which all experiences appear.

This insight frees us from the feeling of separation and the suffering it brings. It invites us to rest in our natural state of being, where peace, love, and unity are inherent.

An Invitation to Self-Inquiry

I invite you to explore these insights not merely as concepts but as pointers to your own direct experience. Open yourself to the possibility that what you truly are is the boundless awareness that is aware of these words right now. In this recognition lies true liberation.

Deepening the Exercises

To assist you further, here are expanded descriptions of exercises that can help you have a more direct experience of the concepts we’ve discussed.

Exercise 1: Discovering the Source of Thoughts

Purpose: To realize that the ‘thinker’ is merely a thought and that thoughts arise spontaneously in consciousness without a separate entity controlling them.

1. Find a Quiet Space: Sit comfortably in a place where you won’t be disturbed. You may sit on a chair with your feet flat on the ground or cross-legged on a cushion.
2. Relax the Body: Close your eyes and take several deep breaths. With each exhalation, allow any tension to release from your body.
3. Bring Attention to Thoughts: Allow your mind to settle without trying to stop your thoughts. Let thoughts arise naturally without directing them.
4. Observe Thoughts: Notice the thoughts that appear—plans, memories, worries, or fantasies. Observe them without judgment or engagement.
5. Ask the Question: Gently inquire, “Who is aware of these thoughts?” or “From where do these thoughts arise?” Let the question resonate without seeking an immediate answer.
6. Search for the Thinker: Look inward to see if you can find an ‘I’ that is the source of these thoughts. Is there a location where this thinker resides?
7. Experience the Absence of a Separate Thinker: You may notice that thoughts simply emerge in awareness without a personal thinker generating them.
8. Recognize Awareness as the Background: Realize that while thoughts come and go, there is an unchanging awareness that knows them.
9. Rest as Awareness: Allow yourself to rest in this sense of being the awareness in which thoughts appear.
10. Integrate the Insight: When ready, gently open your eyes, carrying this understanding into your daily life.

Reflection: Through this exercise, you may discover that the ‘I’ who thinks is unfindable as a separate entity. This realization can lead to a deeper sense of freedom and peace.

Exercise 2: Observing Thoughts as Clouds

Purpose: To let go of identification with thoughts by seeing them as transient phenomena in awareness.

1. Comfortable Posture: Sit or lie down comfortably. Ensure your body is at ease.
2. Use the Breath as an Anchor: Focus on your breathing for a few minutes, following the natural rhythm without altering it.
3. Open to Thoughts: Expand your attention to include thoughts as they arise.
4. Visualize Thoughts as Clouds: Imagine each thought as a cloud drifting across the sky of your mind. Some clouds are light; others are dark, but all pass by.
5. Non-Attachment to Thoughts: When a thought arises, note it without engaging. Silently acknowledge, “A thought about work,” or “A feeling of anxiety,” and let it go.
6. Notice the Space Between Thoughts: Observe the quiet spaces between thoughts—the gaps where stillness resides.
7. Recognize Yourself as the Sky, Not the Clouds: Understand that you are the open, clear awareness in which thoughts come and go.
8. Continue Observing: Practice this for at least ten minutes, maintaining a relaxed and open attention.
9. Apply in Daily Life: Throughout your day, remain aware of thoughts arising and passing without identifying with them.

Reflection: This exercise helps you disidentify from thoughts, recognizing that they do not define who you are. This can lead to greater inner peace and reduced stress.

Exercise 3: Dissolving Duality Through Direct Experience

Purpose: To directly experience that the separation between ‘self’ and ‘other’ is an illusion created by thought.

1. Choose a Sensory Focus: This exercise can be done indoors or outdoors. Select an object or sound to focus on, such as a piece of music, the sight of a tree, or the sensation of the breeze.
2. Give Full Attention: Immerse yourself fully in this sensory experience, letting go of other thoughts and distractions.
3. Avoid Labeling or Analysis: Resist the urge to name or interpret what you perceive. Instead of thinking “I am hearing music,” simply experience the sound without commentary.
4. Let Boundaries Fade: Notice that the experience doesn’t happen to a separate ‘you’; it arises within awareness. Where do you end and the experience begin?
5. Experience Oneness: Allow the sense of a separate observer to dissolve. There is only the seamless unfolding of experience.
6. Deepen into the Experience: Stay with this awareness, letting it deepen naturally. Feel the unity with all that is.
7. Acknowledge Awareness: Recognize that all experiences arise and subside within the same awareness—your true self.
8. Return Gently: When ready, expand your attention to include your surroundings, maintaining the sense of unity.

Reflection: This exercise provides a direct taste of non-dual awareness, where the usual distinctions between self and world fade away.

Exercise 4: Self-Inquiry into the True ‘I’

Purpose: To discover that the sense of a separate ‘I’ is an illusion and that your true nature is awareness itself.

1. Begin with Relaxation: Sit comfortably and close your eyes. Take deep breaths to settle the mind and body.
2. Pose the Central Question: Ask yourself, “Who am I?” Let the question sink in without rushing to answer.
3. Investigate Physical Identification: Consider your body. Ask, “Am I my body?” Notice that the body is ever-changing.
4. Examine Mental Identification: Turn to thoughts and emotions. Ask, “Am I my thoughts? My feelings?” Observe their transient nature.
5. Seek the Unchanging: Is there something in you that is constant, despite these changing experiences?
6. Recognize Awareness: Notice that the one constant is the awareness in which all experiences arise.
7. Rest as Awareness: Allow yourself to simply be this awareness, without effort.
8. Experience the Peace of Your True Nature: Feel the innate stillness and completeness of being awareness itself.
9. Carry the Insight Forward: Open your eyes and continue your day, staying connected to your true self as awareness.

Reflection: This exercise can help dissolve identification with the limited self, revealing a profound connection with your limitless being.

Final Thoughts

Engaging deeply with these exercises creates space for direct experience beyond conceptual understanding. It is in this direct knowing that true transformation occurs. You may find that life itself, in all its simplicity and wonder, continually invites you to recognize your true nature as awareness. This journey is both the path and the destination, and every moment is a fulfillment in itself.

Please follow and like us: